Something I found in Salon.com
On Google's social networking service, Orkut, Indians are organizing themselves by caste. (Thanks to DesiPundit for the tip.) There are hundreds, maybe thousands of groups devoted to every caste, subcaste and sub-sub-caste that exists in India's phenomenally splintered and complex caste system. If, like a typical liberal, you are made uncomfortable by the implicit inequities of caste divisions, then scrolling through the Orkut groups can be a discouraging experience.
"We Agarwals are the people who rule the Business in India, very soon we shall rule over the world too," reads the introduction to one such group. "The whole & soul purpose of this community is to gather all the Brahmins scattered along the Globe & to provide them a common platform to make them re-emerge again as the Leaders of India. This community will help Brahmins to empower them by regaining their lost glory by providing whatever help possible," reads another.
At the same time, distressing as it may be to some, there is nothing surprising about this. It's just yet more proof that cyberspace is hardly a transformative medium. What it's really good at is duplicating, in bits and bytes and packets, exactly the divisions that cut through the offline world.
Which means, naturally, that for every Brahmin group devoted to recovering lost glory, there's a Dalit group aimed at smashing the oppressive system that keeps "untouchables" down. And scores of additional "communities" --"Against the caste system," "I hate caste," "I hate caste and religion" -- that provide gathering places for anti-caste system sentiment.
(But don't dwell too long pondering the twisted irony of a moderator of a Dalit group declaring "I will ban U" to any members of another caste that might try to join her group. Exclusion up and down the hierarchy!)
What to think of it all, besides just the sheer fascination? I'll content myself with a shout out to my favorite discovery, the community "Caste my ass," which illustrates itself with a picture of a donkey, and where one discussion thread begins with a link to a self-congratulatory Brahmin thread and adds the pithy commentary: "The intellectual elite ... my ass."
There you go: that's my caste: "The intellectual elite ... my ass." And you're all welcome to join.
-- Andrew Leonard
Project Gutenberg
Say what!
no comments
2 comments:
'caste' in cyber community as interesting. My take on this is that it is a function of age, technology and tradition. The nature of caste is such that it reproduces, albeit through marriage system.
So, even in cyber world, it manifest...more like a crutch. Since for most of Indians, 'love marriage' is a luxury (inter-caste a high risk), and the 'market' of marriage is still protected.
We know we can always fall back upon tradition unlike the western teenager, who grows up in a competetive environment. There he has to display his individuality to impress others and thus learn more 'aggressive dating behavior'.
It is our underdeveloped dating skills (and ability to manifest individuality)that find refuse in the historical caste based reservation system.
'caste' in orkut is interesting. My take is to view it more as a function of age, technology and tradition. The nature of caste is such that it reproduces, albeit through marriage system.
So, even in cyber world (dominated by marriage age)the caste manifest...more like a 'crutch'. Since for most of Indians, 'love marriage' is still a luxary and high risk (if inter-caste) ,as we are more used to the protected 'market' of marriage. We know we can always fall back upon tradition unlike the western teenager, who grows up in a competetive environment. There he has to display his individuality to impress others and thus learn more 'aggressive dating behavior'.
My contention is that it is our underdeveloped dating skills (or more precisely, ability to manifest 'individuality') is also playing a critical role in continuing with 'caste' groups as a last resort (crutch) in a way that the risks are moderated. Thus unwittingly contributing to the perpetuation of caste, despite 'wishing' to do away with it.
Post a Comment